15 Dec. 1999
Meeting of the North Atlantic Council held at NATO Headquarters, Brussels,
on 15 December 1999
- At our meeting today, we recalled NATO's major achievements in 1999:
- We set forth NATO's vision for the 21st century and approved an
updated Strategic Concept at the Washington Summit, where we also
celebrated the Alliance's 50th Anniversary;
- We admitted as new members the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland;
- We contributed decisively, in particular through the conduct of
our air campaign and the subsequent deployment of KFOR, to the international
community's objective of creating the basis for long-term peace and
stability in Kosovo.
We reviewed progress in implementing the Washington Summit decisions
and took steps to further adapt the Alliance to the new security environment.
We reaffirmed the Alliance's commitment to its fundamental security
tasks, as set out in the Strategic Concept, and the importance of our
individual and collective efforts to achieve our guiding objective of
enhancing the security and stability of the Euro-Atlantic area.
Against the background of political developments in the Balkans, we
reviewed the status of NATO's comprehensive approach and continuing
commitment to the promotion of security, stability, peace and democracy,
and the peaceful resolution of disputes in the region, including through
the NATO-led operations in Bosnia and Herzegovina and in Kosovo, and
the implementation of NATO's South-East Europe Initiative. Through the
Council in Permanent Session and the NATO Military Authorities, we continue
to monitor closely the situation across the region.
We pay tribute to the service-men and women of all nations who are
serving in the Balkans for their professionalism and dedication to the
cause of peace and stability. We express deep sympathy to the families
of those who have lost their lives and to those who have been injured
in the cause of peace.
The Kosovo air campaign, which demonstrated the cohesion and unity
of the Alliance and its determination to act, reinforced the diplomatic
efforts of the international community and achieved the key objectives
of the NATO Allies and their Partners. The humanitarian catastrophe
has ended; some 850,000 refugees have returned; a NATO-led international
peace force (KFOR) has been successfully deployed; and the international
community has assumed responsibility for the civil administration through
the United Nations Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK).
We are determined to play our part in meeting in full the aims of
the international community as set out in UN Security Council Resolution
1244. We remain committed to a peaceful, multi-ethnic and democratic
Kosovo where all peoples can live in peace and security and enjoy universal
human rights and freedoms on an equal basis, including through participation
in democratic institutions.
We noted the progress made in restoring peace and stability since
the deployment of KFOR in Kosovo in accordance with UNSCR 1244, in
particular the reduction in violence and the re-establishment of civil
institutions. We commend the work undertaken by UNMIK and are pleased
with the excellent level of co-ordination and co-operation established
between KFOR and UNMIK. Close civil-military relations are essential
for the success of our common goals and of our peace-building efforts
in the region. In this respect, we have invited the UN Secretary General's
Special Representative, Dr. Kouchner, to tomorrow's meeting of the
Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council.
While progress has been achieved, much remains to be done, in particular
the continued protection of all ethnic groups and minorities. We condemn
all acts of violence and intimidation from whatever quarter. We underline
KFOR's determination to put an end to ethnically motivated violence
and to act swiftly and decisively against all perpetrators, including
through maintaining an effective military presence in Serb minority
areas. We strongly commend KFOR's determination to combat arms trafficking,
illegal possession of weapons, the development of parallel structures
that threaten KFOR or UNMIK objectives or the rule of law, to monitor
and provide security at the borders and boundaries of Kosovo and to
work with UNMIK to avoid cantonisation.
The achievement of the de-militarisation and the dissolution of
the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA) under the supervision of KFOR was
an important step in establishing an environment for post-conflict
reconciliation. We welcome the establishment of a civilian, multi-ethnic
Kosovo Protection Corps (KPC) as another important step in the development
of a civil society for the benefit of all communities. Close control
of the KPC by UNMIK and KFOR is essential. We underscore KFOR's determination
to continue to provide day-to-day operational direction and tasking,
under the overall authority of the United Nations Secretary General's
KFOR will continue to co-operate closely with UNMIK, providing support
to its efforts towards establishing a fully functioning administration
and democratic institutions, promoting the rule of law and respect
for human rights, and assuring the safe return of all refugees and
displaced persons to their homes. It will be vital that UNMIK is adequately
funded and staffed to fulfil its mission, particularly in the area
of local administration and civilian international police. We will
continue to do our utmost to provide a secure environment and we will
give appropriate support for the conduct of free and fair elections
under the auspices of the OSCE, which are to be held next year. We
will also continue to provide strong support for the work of the International
Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.
We urge all community leaders in Kosovo, irrespective of their ethnic
background, to work together and with the international community in
the reconstruction of Kosovo and the establishment of a democratic society
founded on the rule of law, tolerance and respect for human rights.
We call in particular on the leadership of the Kosovar Albanian community
to renounce violence, to demonstrate its commitment to a tolerant, democratic,
multi-ethnic Kosovo, and to co-operate with UNMIK and KFOR against those
who advocate and practice violence. In this context we welcome the creation
by UNMIK of a Joint Interim Administrative Structure, and in particular
the establishment of an Interim Administrative Council. We are encouraged
by Kosovar Albanian agreement to participate in these structures, and
underline the importance of early participation by representatives of
all Kosovar peoples, including the Serb community. We expect all parties
to co-operate fully with the International Criminal Tribunal for the
former Yugoslavia, including by facilitating the conduct of its investigations.
The continuing support of the international community will depend upon
an adequate response to these requirements.
Our common efforts in Kosovo demonstrate the value of the concept
of mutually reinforcing institutions, a concept long championed by the
Alliance. In this respect, our individual bilateral efforts, the substantial
role of the EU and that of other international bodies, are making a
decisive contribution to the economic reconstruction of Kosovo. We also
commend the UNHCR for organising relief efforts and resettlement, the
UN Mine Action Centre for its role in co-ordinating the removal of mines,
and the OSCE for its institution-building, human rights work and training
of Kosovar police. We also express our appreciation for the significant
role played by the many non-governmental organisations.
We express our deep appreciation for the robust practical and political
support provided by Partner countries of the region throughout the air
campaign and thereafter. This support was and remains critical to success.
In particular, we reiterate our appreciation for the ongoing efforts
of Albania and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia in supporting
We are grateful to NATO's Partners and other nations for the substantial
contributions they are making to efforts to bring peace and stability
to the Balkans, which are the practical expressions of these countries'
commitment to our shared values.
The crisis in Kosovo demonstrated the resilience of the Dayton/Paris
Peace Agreement. The Alliance remains committed to supporting a peaceful
future for Bosnia and Herzegovina as a single democratic state composed
of two multi-ethnic Entities, the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina
and the Republika Srpska. We are encouraged by the continuing progress
in the full implementation of the Dayton Agreement. We welcome the appointment
of Ambassador Petritsch as High Representative, whose vigorous approach
to the implementation of the Dayton Agreement we strongly support. We
note in particular the progress made in:
- the development of functioning civil institutions;
- increases in the level of refugee returns, especially to areas
in which returnees are in the minority;
- civil reconstruction;
- reduction in arms holdings; and
- the development of the role of the Standing Committee on Military
We also welcome the progress made in the ongoing arms control and
confidence building negotiations in the framework of the Dayton Agreement
with the goal of establishing a regional balance in and around the
former Yugoslavia. We urge all parties to demonstrate fully their
commitment to the Dayton process and their co-operation with the High
Representative, as the basis for further progress in transferring
administrative responsibility to local authorities.
SFOR has helped to secure a more stable and secure environment in
Bosnia and Herzegovina. As a result, it has been able to undertake significant
restructuring. Early next year a smaller, more flexible force will be
in place and will remain fully capable of carrying out its mandate.
SFOR will continue to contribute to the maintenance of a secure environment
and to give targeted and focused support to civilian implementation.
In this respect, we fully endorse SFOR's close working relationship
with the High Representative and other civil agencies in Bosnia and
Herzegovina, and in particular SFOR's continuing strong support for
the International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) in
bringing indicted war criminals to justice.
Despite this encouraging progress, important challenges remain, such
- the return of displaced persons to minority areas;
- further reduction of both Entities' armed forces;
- further progress in humanitarian de-mining;
- improving the effectiveness of all common institutions, notably
the Parliament of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and co-operation between
- transferring to the ICTY persons indicted for war crimes;
- the fight against corruption, organised crime and illegal secret
- judicial and police reform; and
- the establishment of a state border service.
Accordingly, we expect the Entities to work together fully in co-ordination
with the Presidency, the Council of Ministers and on all other levels.
We applaud the spirit of co-operation exhibited among the common institutions
and between authorities of both Entities during preparations for hosting
the Stability Pact Summit. We call upon the Presidency to implement
in full the commitments made in the New York Declaration of 15 November,
and to support the work of the Standing Committee on Military Matters.
We also demand that all parties fully co-operate with the ICTY, in
particular by surrendering indictees within their territory. Only
on the basis of justice can a lasting peace be established. We emphasise
the fundamental significance of implementing market oriented economic
Taken together, these steps will reinforce the efforts of the High
Representative to make the leaders and authorities of Bosnia and Herzegovina
the "owners" of the process of peace implementation and
open the way to the integration of their country into Euro-Atlantic
institutions. As Co-chair of the Stability Pact Working Table on Security
Issues, Bosnia and Herzegovina can play an important role in promoting
stability in the region.
We remain concerned about continued tensions between Belgrade and
the democratically elected government of Montenegro. We are therefore
paying close attention to developments there. We call on both sides
to resolve their differences in a peaceful and pragmatic way and refrain
from any destabilising measures. We express our support for the objective
of a peaceful and democratic FRY, which protects the rights of all minorities,
including those in Vojvodina and Sandjak. This would open the way for
the eventual return of the FRY to the Euro-Atlantic family of nations.
The forthcoming parliamentary and presidential elections in Croatia
will be crucial for its future. We hope that the entire Croatian leadership
will seize the chance to re-vitalise implementation of the Dayton Peace
Accords, and demonstrate their commitment to democratic elections and
due constitutional process. There is an opportunity for the next Croatian
government to move towards a closer relationship with Euro-Atlantic
Our goal remains the integration of all the countries of South-East
Europe into the Euro-Atlantic Community. To this end, we are building
on the Alliance's already extensive co-operation in the region as evidenced
by NATO's leadership of the SFOR and KFOR operations. The South-East
Europe Initiative, launched at our Washington Summit, is also working
to achieve this goal, including through PfP tools, the EAPC and the
Consultative Forum, which all play valuable roles in our post-conflict
efforts to win permanent peace in the region. Today we received a consolidated
progress report on the South-East Europe Initiative and we note with
satisfaction the range of activities already undertaken, by the countries
in the region and by Allies, with the aim of harmonising assistance
programmes for the states of the region, as appropriate.
NATO's South-East Europe Initiative promotes regional security and
co-operation; it supports and complements the objectives of the Stability
Pact for South-Eastern Europe, adopted by Ministers in Cologne in
June and endorsed by Heads of State and Government at the Sarajevo
Summit in July. NATO is participating fully in the work of the Regional
Table and the Working Tables established to implement the Stability
Pact. The Alliance will continue to contribute to the success of the
Stability Pact by making available its wealth of experience and expertise
in practical military and defence-related co-operation and by ensuring
that our efforts complement and contribute to the goals of the Pact.
We welcome the constructive contribution of Partners and other nations
of South-East Europe to the stabilisation of that region. We applaud
the engagement of Montenegro in the Stability Pact and look forward
to the time when the FRY will be able to play its rightful part in
We direct the Council in Permanent session to pursue vigorously
the various efforts under the South-East Europe Initiative and the
Alliance's contribution to the objectives of the Stability Pact, and
to report on progress by the time of our next meeting.
In its Strategic Concept, NATO has committed itself to contribute
to effective conflict prevention. Our common efforts to build peace
and security in Kosovo, to support a peaceful future for Bosnia and
Herzegovina and to enhance co-operation, including security co-operation,
in South-Eastern Europe, are examples of such contributions by the Alliance,
as are the recent initiatives to promote practical regional co-operation
in the EAPC/PfP framework. We direct the Council in Permanent Session
to continue to consider means to ensure an effective and coherent Alliance
contribution to the efforts of the international community to prevent
and defuse conflicts, and to make recommendations where and if appropriate.
Our experience in Kosovo has confirmed that NATO must continue to
adapt and improve its defence capabilities to ensure the effectiveness
of future multinational operations across the full range of Alliance
missions. Implementation of the Defence Capabilities Initiative (DCI),
agreed in Washington, will ensure that NATO's forces can meet the challenges
of mobility, deployability, sustainability, effective engagement, survivability
and interoperable and effective command, control and communications
systems. The DCI will also promote greater interoperability among Alliance
forces and, where applicable, between Allied and Partner forces. The
DCI is essential to strengthening European defence capabilities and
the European pillar of NATO, so that European Allies will be able to
make a stronger and more coherent contribution to NATO. It will also
improve their capability to undertake EU-led operations where the Alliance
as a whole is not engaged. We are encouraged by the useful initial results
achieved to date in implementing the DCI and look forward to further
essential improvements in Alliance defence capabilities. Though the
implementation of DCI is first and foremost a national responsibility,
the provision of adequate resources, including multinational, joint
and common funding arrangements, will be a critical factor.
The development of an effective ESDI will strengthen the Alliance,
through which we remain ready to pursue common security objectives wherever
possible. We are committed to reinforcing the Alliance's European pillar.
Building on existing arrangements between NATO and the WEU as agreed
in Berlin, and reaffirmed at our Washington Summit, we support the development
within NATO of separable but not separate capabilities which could respond
to European requirements and contribute to Alliance security. These
developments will also result in a stronger and more balanced transatlantic
We have set in train work on the development of the European Security
and Defence Identity within the Alliance as set out in the Washington
Summit Communiqué and the Strategic Concept. In this context,
we have initiated discussions in the Alliance to address means to ensure
the development of effective mutual consultation, co-operation and transparency,
building on the mechanisms existing between NATO and the WEU; participation
of non-EU European Allies; as well as practical arrangements for assured
EU access to NATO planning capabilities and for ready EU access to NATO
collective assets and capabilities on a case-by-case basis and by consensus
as set out at Washington.
Alliance work will proceed on the Washington Summit agenda, on an
ongoing basis, taking into account the evolution of relevant arrangements
in the EU. In this regard, we note the results of the European Council
meeting in Helsinki on the strengthening of the common European policy
on security and defence and on the development of modalities for EU/NATO
relations, which represent a major contribution to the process of reinforcing
our Alliance and its European pillar. We acknowledge the resolve of
the European Union to have the capacity for autonomous action so that
it can take decisions and approve military action where the Alliance
as a whole is not engaged. We note that this process will avoid unnecessary
duplication and does not imply the creation of a European army. In this
- We note the European Union's decision to set a common European
headline goal and to develop collective capability goals to improve
European military capabilities. The contribution of the non-EU European
Allies to this process is and will be important. We applaud the
determination of all European Allies to take the necessary steps
to strengthen their defence capabilities. The EU's headline and
capability goals and the objectives arising from NATO's DCI will
be mutually reinforcing, using - subject to the necessary decisions
- existing defence planning procedures including, as appropriate,
those available in NATO and the Planning and Review Process of the
PfP, noting that in addition EU Ministers will develop a method
of consultation and a regular review of progress made.
- We reiterate our readiness to define and adopt, in accordance
with our decisions taken in Washington, the necessary arrangements
for European Union ready access to separable but not separate NATO
collective assets and capabilities, for operations in which the
Alliance as a whole is not engaged militarily as an Alliance, respecting
the requirements of NATO operations and the coherence of its command
- We note the decision of the EU to set up, in future, appropriate
structures to ensure the necessary dialogue, consultation and co-operation
with European NATO members which are not members of the EU on issues
related to European security and defence policy and crisis management.
In this respect, we underline, as we did at the Washington Summit,
the importance of finding solutions satisfactory to all Allies,
for the necessary involvement of non-EU European Allies in these
We note that the non-EU European NATO members will participate,
if they so wish, in the event of an operation involving the use
of NATO assets and capabilities, and that they will be invited,
upon decision by the EU, to take part in other EU-led operations.
We see these EU decisions as important steps to achieve the goals
envisaged by our Heads of State and Government at the Washington
Summit. Participation of non-EU European Allies will enhance the
effectiveness of EU-led military operations and will contribute
directly to the effectiveness and vitality of the European pillar
- We recognise the European Union's decision to establish permanent
political and military structures and interim bodies, and its commitment
to develop, under the Portuguese Presidency, modalities for full
consultation, co-operation and transparency between NATO and the
EU. We note that this, as with all the tasks entrusted to the Portuguese
Presidency, is to be carried forward as a matter of priority. We
reciprocate the EU's intention to develop appropriate modalities
for a close and confident relationship between the two organisations.
We welcome as a first step the informal contacts between the NATO
Secretary General and the EU High Representative for Common Foreign
and Security Policy.
We welcome the participation in our discussions of Dr. Javier Solana.
As Secretary General of the Western European Union, his presence symbolises
the close relationship that has developed between NATO and the WEU.
The Alliance continues to work with the WEU to complete and implement
arrangements to facilitate co-operation between the two organisations
in the event of a WEU-led military operation using NATO assets and capabilities.
We look forward to exercising these arrangements in a crisis management
exercise between NATO and the WEU scheduled for February 2000.
We direct the Council in Permanent Session to proceed with its work
as set out at the Washington Summit, taking into account the developments
described above, and report to us at our next meeting.
The Alliance reaffirms its commitment to remain open to new members.
The Alliance expects to extend further invitations in coming years to
nations willing and able to assume the responsibilities and obligations
of membership, and as NATO determines that the inclusion of these nations
would serve the overall political and strategic interests of the Alliance
and the inclusion would enhance overall European security and stability.
The three new members will not be the last.
At the Washington Summit, NATO Heads of State and Government approved
a Membership Action Plan (MAP) to reinforce NATO's commitment to the
openness of the Alliance. We have received today a report on the implementation
of the MAP to date. We are pleased that the MAP process has made an
effective start and met with a positive response of the nine aspiring
countries. Aspirants have submitted annual national programmes which
enable the Alliance to provide them with direct advice, feedback and
assistance on their preparations for possible future membership.
We encourage all aspirants to set themselves realistic, prioritised
goals and timelines and to allocate the necessary resources to them.
We stand ready to assist the aspirants in their efforts to meet the
goals they have set. To this end, we will develop with them Planning
Targets in the defence/military field and tailored PfP Individual Partnership
Programmes. Meetings of the Council will take place next Spring with
each aspirant to examine progress made. We will keep the enlargement
process, including implementation of the MAP, under continual review.
We expect the annual consolidated progress report on activities under
the MAP at our next Ministerial.
The Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council remains the key forum for regular
consultation on security and defence related issues between the Alliance
and its Partners. We welcome the expansion of activities within the
EAPC/PfP framework to promote practical co-operation, including regional
co-operation notably in South-East Europe, as well as in the Caucasus
and Central Asia. Enhanced co-operation in support of, inter alia, peacekeeping,
global humanitarian mine action and addressing the challenges of small
arms and light weapons underline the role of the EAPC as a vital and
dynamic institution in enhancing security in the Euro-Atlantic area.
We are pleased with the progress made in implementing the Washington
Summit decision to further enhance the Partnership for Peace and make
it more operational. We welcome the approval of the first Ministerial
Guidance of the PfP Planning and Review Process (PARP) and the development
of Partnership goals as a substantial step forward in bringing the force
planning processes of Partners closer to those of Allies. We also welcome
the progress that has been made in involving Partners as troop contributing
nations in consultations, planning, conduct and political oversight
of the present operations in the Balkans, in accordance with the Political-Military
Framework (PMF) for NATO-led PfP operations. We endorse the Operational
Capabilities Concept which will reinforce PfP's operational capabilities
and improve the capability and interoperability of Partner forces, as
well as enhance the Alliance's overall ability to put together tailored
force packages to mount and sustain future NATO-led PfP operations along
the lines of SFOR and KFOR. The Concept will continue to evolve. We
appreciate the substantial progress achieved so far on the Training
and Education Enhancement Programme. We look forward to a report by
the Council in Permanent Session on progress made on these important
initiatives at our Spring 2000 meeting.
We welcome the recent signing by Ireland of the PfP Framework Document
and we look forward to close co-operation with Ireland in the PfP and
We continue to attach importance to consultations and practical co-operation
with Russia. Our aim remains to establish a strong, stable and enduring
partnership within the framework of the NATO-Russia Founding Act.
We note the progress made in recent consultations in the PJC framework
on issues relating to the operation in Kosovo. We note with satisfaction
the valuable experience of practical co-operation between NATO and Russian
forces both in SFOR and KFOR.
We encourage Russia to resume co-operation on the broad range of
issues foreseen in the Founding Act and to engage actively in the EAPC
and the Partnership for Peace. At the same time, we emphasise that the
further development of our co-operation depends on Russia's respect
for international norms and obligations.
We are deeply concerned about the conflict in Chechnya, continuing
reports of civilian casualties there and the plight of displaced persons.
We condemn, in particular, Russian threats against unarmed civilians,
such as those in Grozny. We acknowledge the right of Russia to preserve
its territorial integrity and to protect its citizens against terrorism
and lawlessness. We condemn terrorism in all its manifestations but
believe that Russia's pursuit of a purely military solution to the conflict
is undermining its legitimate objectives. The continuing disproportionate
and indiscriminate use of force against the civilian population is incompatible
with the commitments Russia has undertaken within the OSCE and its obligations
as a member of the United Nations and the Council of Europe. In this
context, we also recall the principles enshrined in the NATO-Russia
Founding Act. We therefore urge Russia to exercise the fullest restraint,
to refrain from the use of force against civilians and protect their
human rights, to facilitate the provision of humanitarian aid to those
in need, and to co-operate fully with international relief agencies
and to ensure security for their operations. Bearing in mind the importance
of regional stability and respect for the territorial integrity and
sovereignty of neighbouring states, we are deeply concerned about the
impact of the crisis of the entire Caucasus region and stress the need
to avoid steps that would further undermine regional security.
We urge Russia to open all avenues for a political solution to the conflict.
To this end, it is essential that the Russian government and Chechen
representatives take meaningful steps toward a renewed dialogue. We
also urge the Chechen authorities to condemn terrorism and to take action
against it. We expect Russia to respect the commitments made in Istanbul
and to make good use of today's visit by the OSCE Chairman-in-Office
to the region in order to facilitate a political process to end the
We welcome the progressive development of the NATO-Ukraine distinctive
partnership in accordance with the Charter signed in Madrid in 1997.
We are pleased that this partnership is providing a framework for co-operative
initiatives such as the NATO Information and Documentation Centre in
Kyiv, which is actively engaged with Ukrainian media, universities and
think-tanks. We also note that a NATO Liaison Office has been operational
in Kyiv since April, and is providing a valuable contribution to facilitating
Ukraine's full participation in the Partnership for Peace programme
and more generally, to enhancing co-operation between NATO and Ukrainian
We continue to support the efforts of the Joint Working Group on
Defence Reform and remain prepared to provide advice, as appropriate,
to assist Ukraine with the transformation of its defence establishment.
In the economic area, we welcome the initiation of a programme for the
retraining of retired military officers. Co-operation is also developing
in the fields of civil emergency planning, air-traffic management, armaments-related
partnership activities, defence research and technology, and science.
We reiterate our view that a speedy ratification of the Status of Forces
Agreement by Ukraine will further the goals of our co-operation.
We encourage Ukraine to move forward with its democratic and economic
reforms, and reaffirm NATO's support for Ukraine's efforts to this end.
In this context, we welcome Ukraine's commitment to exploit the full
potential of the NATO-Ukraine Charter and express our appreciation for
Ukraine's concrete contribution to peace and stability in the Balkans,
in particular through its participation in KFOR. We look forward to
today's meeting of the NATO-Ukraine Commission in Foreign Ministers'
The Mediterranean Dialogue is an integral part of the Alliance's
co-operative approach to security since security in the whole of Europe
is closely linked to security and stability in the Mediterranean. We
are pleased with the progress achieved in strengthening the Mediterranean
Dialogue as agreed at the Washington Summit. The last round of political
consultations with the six Mediterranean Dialogue countries held in
October and November, offered an opportunity for sharing views on the
implementation and future development of the Dialogue, including the
Work Programme for 2000. We recognise the interest of our Mediterranean
partners in developing the Dialogue, including through a strengthened
co-operation in areas where NATO can bring added value.
We acknowledge the role played by the recently-designated Contact
Point Embassies and we encourage the Mediterranean Co-operation Group
to continue its efforts to progressively develop the Dialogue. Visits
by NATO representatives have improved the prospects for closer contacts
and co-operation. We welcome and encourage Allied nations and Mediterranean
Dialogue countries to organise events such as the Rome Conference in
1997 and the Valencia Conference in 1999, as positive steps to strengthen
mutual regional understanding. We direct the Council in Permanent Session
to report at our next meeting on the political and practical co-operation
in the Dialogue agreed in Washington.
We welcome the adoption of the OSCE Istanbul Charter on European
Security, in particular the emphasis in the Charter on closer co-operation
among international organisations. We also welcome the adoption of the
Platform for Co-operative Security. The adoption of the Vienna Document
1999 on Confidence and Security Building Measures constitutes an important
step towards increased transparency in military matters among OSCE participating
states. We look forward to further intensifying co-operation between
NATO and OSCE, notably in the areas of conflict prevention, peacekeeping,
crisis management and post-conflict rehabilitation.
We reaffirm that arms control, disarmament and non-proliferation
will continue to play an important role in the achievement of NATO's
The Agreement on the Adaptation of the Treaty on Conventional Armed
Forces in Europe, signed at the OSCE Summit in Istanbul on 19 November,
will ensure the continuing viability of the CFE Treaty as a cornerstone
of European security and stability. The Allies made comprehensive proposals
which served as an important basis for the negotiations, in particular
for the introduction of a system of nationally based equipment limits
and improvements to the Treaty provisions concerning stability, transparency
and predictability. The Adapted Treaty will enhance security throughout
Europe, not least as it introduces a more constraining structure of
National and Territorial Ceilings, while permitting sufficient deployment
flexibility for routine training purposes and effective crisis management,
thereby ensuring NATO's ability to fulfil its responsibilities. We are
pleased that the Adapted Treaty will permit accession by new States
Parties and strengthen Treaty requirements concerning host nation consent
to the presence of foreign forces.
We welcome the important political commitments contained in the CFE
Final Act, in particular the bilateral agreements reached by Russia
and Georgia, and Russia and Moldova, on withdrawal of Russian Forces.
But it is essential that the CFE Treaty remains effective and credible.
NATO countries are concerned about continued Russian non-compliance
with the Treaty's Article V («flank») limits. We note Russia's
commitment to comply with all the Treaty's provisions and limitations.
We also note Russia's assurances that its exceeding of CFE limits will
be of a temporary nature. NATO Allies expect Russia to honour its pledge
to comply with CFE limits as soon as possible and, in the meantime,
to provide maximum transparency regarding its forces and weapons deployed
in the North Caucasus, in accordance with the CFE Treaty and the Vienna
Document. Entry into Force of the Adapted Treaty can only be envisaged
in the context of compliance by all States Parties with the Treaty's
limitations. It is on this basis that we will work towards bringing
the Adapted Treaty into force. Pending the completion of this process,
the continued implementation of the existing Treaty and its associated
documents remains crucial.
The Alliance attaches importance to preserving strategic stability.
In this respect, we call on Russia to ratify the START II Treaty without
delay. This would pave the way for considerable reductions of nuclear
arsenals and would allow negotiations on a START III Treaty aiming at
further far-reaching reductions on nuclear weapons stockpiles. We underscore
the importance of achieving a successful conclusion to the upcoming
Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty Review Conference in Spring 2000. In
this context, we reiterate our full support of all efforts towards universal
adherence, full implementation and further strengthening the NPT as
the cornerstone of the nuclear non-proliferation regime and the essential
foundation for the pursuit of nuclear disarmament. We reaffirm our commitment
to efforts aimed at reducing nuclear weapons.
We remain committed to an early entry into force of the Comprehensive
Test Ban Treaty and call upon all countries to accede to and implement
the Treaty as soon as possible. We call for the early start of negotiations
on a Fissile Material Cut-off Treaty.
The prevention of the proliferation of WMD and their means of delivery
remains our primary aim. We remain committed to preventing proliferation
and reversing it where it has occurred through diplomatic means. We
recognise that proliferation of nuclear, biological and chemical (NBC)
weapons and their means of delivery, which pose a potential threat to
the Allies' populations, territory and forces, can continue to occur
despite our preventive efforts and can pose a direct military threat
to those populations, territories and forces.
We continue to attach the utmost importance to full implementation
and rigorous verification of international disarmament and non-proliferation
regimes. We note with satisfaction that the implementation of the
Chemical Weapons Convention is proceeding well and welcome the progress
made in the negotiations in Geneva on a legally binding Protocol to
strengthen the Biological Weapons Convention by ensuring effective
verification measures to enhance compliance and promote transparency.
We urge that additional efforts be made to complete the remaining
work as soon as possible before the Fifth Review Conference of the
BWC in 2001.
We welcome the progress made by the Alliance in implementing the
Initiative on Weapons of Mass Destruction. NATO's new WMD Centre, which
we expect to be operational in early 2000, will provide an effective
additional means to address both the political and defence challenges
of the proliferation of NBC weapons and their means of delivery, and
will promote more active and regular intra-Alliance consultations and
co-operation on this important issue. Significant progress has been
made in setting in place an enhanced WMD intelligence database and information
repository, which will aim at improving the quality and increasing the
quantity of intelligence and information sharing among Allies to support
efforts by NATO members to address proliferation issues. We support
deepening consultations with Russia in these areas within the Permanent
Joint Council, as well as with Ukraine in the NATO-Ukraine Commission
and with other Partners in the EAPC, as well as with the Mediterranean
At the Washington Summit, our leaders committed the Alliance to
consider options for confidence and security building measures, verification,
non-proliferation and arms control and disarmament, in the light of
overall strategic developments and the reduced salience of nuclear
weapons. We have decided to set in train this process and have instructed
the Council in Permanent Session to task the Senior Political Committee,
reinforced by political and defence experts as appropriate, to review
Alliance policy options in support of confidence and security building
measures, verification, non-proliferation, and arms control and disarmament,
so that a comprehensive and integrated approach to the accomplishment
of the remit agreed at the Washington Summit is ensured. The responsible
NATO bodies will contribute to this review. We have directed the Council
in Permanent Session to submit a report to Ministers for their consideration
in December 2000. We believe that this process will reinforce the
Allies' contribution in advancing confidence and security building
measures, verification, non-proliferation and arms control and disarmament.
In order to enhance the effectiveness of Civil-Military Co-operation,
confirmed in the Strategic Concept as essential to the Alliance's
operational capability, a fundamental review of civil emergency planning
in NATO is nearing completion. We welcome the progress made. A close
working relationship between the civil and military communities will
contribute to a more effective use of Allied and Partner civilian
resources in Alliance activities such as peace support operations.
We look forward to the completion of this review at an early date.
We will continue and consolidate the excellent co-operation with Partners
in this field, including through the Euro-Atlantic Disaster Response
Co-ordination Centre, which played an important role in contributing
to the relief of the humanitarian crisis in and around Kosovo, and
in supporting Allied national authorities following recent natural
Terrorism constitutes a serious threat to peace, security and stability
that can threaten the territorial integrity of States. We reiterate
our condemnation of terrorism and reaffirm our determination to combat
it in accordance with our international commitments and national legislation.
The terrorist threat against deployed NATO forces and NATO installations
requires the consideration and development of appropriate measures
for their continued protection taking full account of host nation
At the Washington Summit our leaders took the steps to ensure that
our Alliance will remain the bedrock of our collective defence, and
continue to play a key role in the development of a secure and stable
peace in the Euro-Atlantic area. Today, as we enter the 21st century,
we can state with confidence that NATO is ready to face the challenges
of the future.