Books
The International Criminal Tribunal for the Former
Yugoslavia: An Exercise in Law, Politics, and Diplomacy / Rachel Kerr - Oxford,
UK: Oxford University Press, 2003.
On 25 May 1993, the United Nations Security
Council took the extraordinary and unprecedented step of deciding to establish
the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) as a
mechanism for the restoration and maintenance of international peace and
security. This was an extremely significant innovation in the use of mandatory
enforcement powers by the Security Council, and the manifestation of an
explicit link between peace and justice, and politics and law. The
establishment of ad hoc tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda was
followed by the adoption of the Rome Statute of the ICC in July 1998, the
arrest of General Augusto Pinochet in London in October 1998, and the
establishment of ad hoc tribunals in Cambodia, Sierra Leone, and East Timor,
all of which pointed to an emerging norm of international criminal justice. The
key to understanding this is the relationship between the political mandate and
the judicial function. The Tribunal was established as a tool of politics, but
it was a judicial, not a political, tool. This book provides a systematic
examination of the Tribunal, what it is, why it was established, how it
functions, and where its significance lies. The central question is whether an
international judicial institution such as the Tribunal can operate in a highly
politicized context and fulfil an explicit political purpose, without the
judicial process becoming politicized. Separate chapters chart the origins of
the court; the process of establishment; jurisdictional procedure; state
cooperation, including obtaining custody of the accused; and the role and
function of the Chief Prosecutor. This last element is the key to the
Tribunal's success in maintaining a delicate balancing act so that its external
political function does not impinge on its impartial judicial status, and
instead enhances its effectiveness. The book concludes with an assessment of
the conduct of the Milosevic case to date.
Homeland Calling: Exile Patriotism and the Balkan
Wars / Paul Hockenos - Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2003.
Over the last ten years, many commentators have
tried to describe and analyze the bloody conflicts that tore Yugoslavia apart.
But in all these attempts to make sense of the wars and ethnic violence, one
crucial factor has been overlooked - the major, often decisive, role played by
exile groups and emigre communities in fanning the flames of nationalism and
territorial ambition. Based in the United States, Canada, Europe, Australia,
and South America, some groups helped provide the ideologies, the leadership,
the money, and in many cases, the military hardware that fueled the violent
conflicts. Atypical were the dissenting voices who drew upon their experience
in Western democracies to stem the tide of war. In spite of the diaspora's
power and influence, however, their story has never before been told, partly
because it is so difficult, even dangerous, to unravel. The author, a
Berlin-based American journalist and political analyst, has traveled through
several continents and interviewed scores of key figures, many of whom had
never previously talked about their activities. The author investigates the
borderless international networks that diaspora organizations rely on to export
political agendas back to their native homelands - agendas that at times
blatantly undermined the foreign policy objectives of their adopted countries.
Milosevic: A Biography / Adam LeBor - London:
Bloomsbury, 2003.
Slobodan Milosevic is a man the world hoped it
would never see again. His leadership prompted four bloody wars and horrific
ethnic cleansing, which drove Yugoslavia into the ground, and yet for a decade
he managed to wrap the local media and the international community around his
little finger. In this first authoritative biography, the author documents
Milosevic's deeply unhappy childhood, his all-important marriage to Mira and
his personal and public relationships, and explains his dramatic rise to power,
the looted money (estimated at $30 billion), international politics, illicit
ventures and powerful loyalties. This fascinating story leads to Milosevic's
inevitable fall from grace and his trial at the International Criminal Tribunal
in The Hague for crimes against humanity.
War in the Balkans, 1991-2002 / R. Craig Nation -
Carlisle Barracks, PA: US Army War College, 2003.
This book was written to address the need for a
comprehensive history of the Balkan wars provoked by the collapse of the
Yugoslav Federation in 1991. These wars, and the instability that they have
provoked, became preoccupations for international security management through
the 1990s. After an initial phase of distancing and hesitation, Balkan conflict
drew the United States and its most important European allies into an
open-ended commitment to peace enforcement, conflict management, and
peace-building in the region, importantly supported by the US Army. These
efforts are still underway, and significant tensions and potential flashpoints
remain in place within former Yugoslavia and the entire Southeastern European
area. The lessons learned from the new Balkan wars, and the successes and
failures of US and international engagement, provide a significant foundation
for future efforts to manage intractable regional conflict. The Balkan conflict
of the 1990s, as a case study in state failure and medium intensity warfare,
international conflict management and intervention, and US military engagement,
provides an excellent framework for asking basic questions about the dynamic of
international security at the dawn of a new millennium. This book is intended
to provide a foundation for addressing such questions by surveying events in
both contemporary and larger historical perspectives and posing preliminary
conclusions concerning their larger meaning.
Neither War Nor Not War: Army Command in Europe
During the Time of Peace Operations: Tasks Confronting USAREUR Commanders, 1994-2000
/ Richard Moody Swain-Carlisle Barracks, PA: US Army War College, 2003.
With the removal of Saddam Hussein's regime, the
US Army has again demonstrated its prowess at warfighting. But while two wars
against Iraq have gained the most attention for the Army, its ability to
undertake complex less-than-war missions is equally important for the promotion
of US national interests. To a large extent, the Army developed its skill at
tasks like peace operations 'on the fly' in the 1990s when it was committed to
places like Somalia and, most importantly, the Balkans. As with any new
endeavor, mistakes were made, but most were quickly corrected. By the turn of
the 21st century, the Army has developed impressive skill at large, complex
peace operations. This study is a seminal contribution to the analysis of the
Army's role in the Balkans. The author's mission was to analyze the Bosnia
peace operation from the perspective of US military leaders. To do this, the
author collected an immense amount of primary source material, much of it
unavailable to other analysts. The result is a work that is of interest to both
scholars and military leaders.
The History of Serbia / John K. Cox - Westport,
CT: Greenwood Press, 2002.
Shattering Yugoslavia in 1991, the outbreak of war
turned the world's eyes to the Balkans. Interest in the region's history
increased as the war escalated, yet the emotional charge surrounding the
Balkans' recent tribulations can threaten objectivity. A level perspective is
required when confronting the complex web of Serbian history, politics,
society, and culture. This balanced and engaging written history of Serbia
dissects how its citizens have dealt with enormous political, military, and
socioeconomic challenges. In addition to examining the politics of Serbia in
the context of Central Europe, the author shows how societal and cultural
developments affected Serbia and reflected political and economic events. His
study removes the veils of stereotype and myth, which have often obscured
significant details and developmental processes in Serbia's history. This book
includes : A timeline of significant events in Serbia's history; An
introductory chapter on Serbia today; Twelve chronologically organized
narratives ranging from the splendor of medieval Serbia to a new beginning
after the downfall of Slobodan Milosevic; Four historical maps; Brief
biographies of key figures; A glossary of terms; A bibliographic essay
providing valuable resource material for readers.
Bosnia after Dayton: Nationalist Partition and
International Intervention / Sumantra Bose - London: Hurst, 2002.
Since 1996, Bosnia and Herzegovina has been the
site of a remarkable project of political engineering. A complex consortium of
international agencies backed by Western governments have been transforming a
devastated, ethnically partitioned, post-war territory into a multiethnic,
democratic and economically viable state. Despite an enourmous investment of
personnel and resources, six years later BiH's post-Yugoslav future remains
tenuous. Did the engineering project work ? In an era when countries from
Somalia to Afghanistan are confronting questions of state legitimacy amidst
international intervention, this book is a fascinating study on the dilemmas of
the post-Cold War international order. How effective are international
'peace-building' interventions in fractured states ? Is the preservation of a
multinational state desirable - or even possible - where the majority of
citizens only reluctantly acknowledges its legitimacy ? Drawing on the author's
extensive field experience, this book takes a hard look at the issues that
Bosnia continues to face. Juxtaposing big-picture analysis with an intimate
knowledge of the region, Bose situates the international community's extensive
program of state-building and democratization in BiH since the Dayton Peace
Agreement in the context of Bosnia's - and the former Yugoslavia's - complex
historical legacy of coexistence and conflict. Bose tells the gripping story of
the divided city of Mostar, and analyzes the post-Dayton institutional
structure and process. He dissects the making of the Dayton peace accords
through American-led coercive diplomacy, and provides a constructive critique of
international peace-building.
U.S. Policy Toward the Former Yugoslavia / Stevan
E. Meyer - Washington: Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, 2002.
For the United States, the period since 1990 has
been a time of confusion, conflicting signals, arrogance, misunderstanding,
anomie, and ultimately, failure as successive administrations tried to figure
out what American policy toward the Balkans should be. As the author tries to
clear away the underbrush of this period, four distinct periods in US policy
toward Yugoslavia can be discerned. Hopefully, understanding these periods will
help point the way to a more creative, positive, and successful US policy
toward the former Yugoslavia.
NATO's Balkan Interventions / Dana H. Allin -
Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2002.
The terrorist mass murders of 11 September 2001
transformed transatlantic priorities, drawing a line under a decade in which
the wars of Yugoslavia's collapse dominated the transatlantic security
relationship. Yet, despite progress in the region, Balkan instability retains
the capacity to punish Western inattention, much as it did in the early 1990s.
This paper examines NATO's Balkan interventions over the entire decade starting
with the break-up of Yugoslavia in 1992. Focusing on the wars in Bosnia and
Kosovo, it traces the record of early transatlantic failures and later
successes as once bitterly divided allies were able, finally, to unite around
some basic principles. By the time of the Kosovo intervention in Spring 1999,
the allies agreed on the necessity of taking sides and using military force in
conflicts that were complicated, but far from morally opaque. The paper
concludes with some lessons around which the transatlantic allies might
reasonably hope - despite other pressing concerns - to stay engaged and stay
united.
Indictment at The Hague: The Milosevic Regime and
Crimes of the Balkan War / Norman L. Cigar, Paul R. Williams - New York: New
York University Press, 2002.
This book represents the most detailed examination
of the conduct of the Milosevic regime and the individual responsibility of the
senior members of its leadership for war crimes in Croatia and
Bosnia-Herzegovina. The enquiry which forms the basis of this book, making a
case and defining the grounds for the indictment of Milosevic, was initiated at
a time when there appeared to be little, if any, prospect of the international
community promoting an investigation, much less a formal indictment of those
responsible for the war crimes. The indictments finally issued by the Tribunal
are a confirmation of the validity of the argument and evidence presented here.
This book therefore can be read as a detailed 'case study' which defines the
nature and legal responsibility of a regime in the commission of war crimes and
analyzes the legal and evidentiary facets that eventually formed the basis of
the Tribunal's indictment of Slobodan Milosevic.
The War in Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina,
1991-1995 / ed. By Branka Magas and Ivo Zanic - London: Frank Cass, 2001.
It is not often that the world is able to watch a
war day by day on the television screen, as was the case with the recent wars
in Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina. But despite the unprecedented media
coverage, and despite the fact that these two interdependent wars were the
greatest armed conflicts in Europe in the second half of the twentieth century,
they have not been systematically studied with a view to understanding their
background and conduct; nor have practical lessons been drawn in anything more
than a general manner. This is all the more surprising since their impact on
the region's political landscape is still visible today and is likely to
continue for the foreseeable future. A realistic understanding of these wars is
vital in building a sound basis for the future of the successor states of
former Yugoslavia, and for better relations between them. An analysis of their
successes and failures is needed to serve the establishment of more stable and
cooperative regional security. This volume examines both wars as part of an
interrelated political-military process and includes the lively discussions
among the participants.
The Kosovo Conflict and International Law: An
Analytical Documentation, 1974-1999 / ed. by Heike Krieger - Cambridge, MA:
Cambridge University Press, 2001.
This book provides international lawyers, scholars
and students with access to material on the conflict in Kosovo. As well as the
basic material relating to Kosovo's status in Yugoslavia before 1999, this
volume reproduces the significant documentation on the following issues: the
development of the human rights situation, the diplomatic efforts for the
settlement of the crisis, the military action against Yugoslavia and the
international community's response, court action with regard to the conflict,
and the implementation of the principles for a political solution with an
international civil and security presence in Kosovo. An analytical introduction
provides the historical and political context as well as an overview of the
various legal aspects of the conflict. A chronology and detailed index make the
documents more accessible.
Under Orders : War Crimes in Kosovo - New York:
Human Rights Watch, 2001.
This report documents the murders, rapes, forced
expulsions, and other war crimes committed by Serbian and Yugoslav government
forces against Kosovar Albanians between March 24 and June 12, 1999, the period
of NATO's air campaign against Yugoslavia. The report documents a coordinated
and systematic campaign to terrorize, kill, and expel the ethnic Albanians of
Kosovo that was organized b the highest levels of the Serbian and Yugoslav
governments in power at that time. The report also describes serious abuses
committed by the Kosovo Liberation Army, which abducted and murdered civilians
during and after the war, as well as by NATO, which failed to adequately
minimize civilian casualites during its bombing of Yugoslavia. The primary
focus, however, is the Serbian and Yugoslav state-sponsored violence inflicted
against ethnic Albanian citizens of Yugoslavia.
The Third Yugoslavia, 1992-2001 / Sabrina P. Ramet
- Washington: Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, 2001.
The third Yugoslavia was born on April 27, 1992,
when Serbia and Montenegro proclaimed the establishment of the Federal Republic
of Yugoslavia (FRY).
The Conflict over Kosovo: Why Milosevic Decided to
Settle When He Did / Stephen T. Holmer - Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation,
2001.
This report examines the reasons Slobodan
Milosevic, the then president of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, decided on
June 3, 1999, to accept NATO's conditions for terminating the conflict over
Kosovo. Drawing in part upon the testimony of Milosevic and other senior Serb
and foreign officials who directly interacted with Milosevic, the report
analyzes (1) the assumptions and other calculations that underlay Milosevic's
initial decision to defy NATO's demands with regard to Kosovo, and (2) the
political, economic, and military developments and pressures, and the resulting
expectations and concerns that most importantly influenced his subsequent
decision to come to terms.
Some Reverberations from the the Kosovo War / C. J
Dick - Camberley, UK: Conflict Studies Research Centre, 2001.
The war in Kosovo may well prove to have been a
turning point in the development of the post-Cold War world. As a result of it,
international perceptions of NATO and, to a lesser extent, the alliance's
perception of itself, have changed. In consequence, many countries' attitudes
towards the alliance and to their own security affairs may also have changed.
The war has also shaken yet again the kaleidoscope that is the territory of
former Yugoslavia. These changes form the subject of this paper.
Waging Modern War: Bosnia, Kosovo, and the Future
of Combat / Wesley K. Clark - Oxford, UK: PublicAffairs, 2001.
Ugly, shocking, frightening, war came to Europe
once more in March 1999. The world watched in dismay as Yugoslavia's military
machine attacked its own citizens in the province of Kosovo. As had happened so
often since the end of the Cold War, ethnic conflict had turned deadly, and the
great powers seemed reluctant to get involved. This time, however, the United
States and its allies intervened. Using an innovative, high-technology air
operation, NATO brought modern military power to bear against Serb forces in
the field and the machinery of repression that backed them up. It was modern
war - limited in scope, measured in effect, extraordinarily complex in
execution. And in the end, after ten weeks of steadily intensifying air attack,
the Yugoslav troops were withdrawn and the Kosovar Albanians returned to their
homes. Remarkably, the alliance held together despite the strains of war and
the tug of differing national interests. In this book, the author recounts not
only the events that led to armed conflict, but also the context within which
he made the key strategic decisions. The author also describes, for the first
time, how he walked the tightrope of high diplomacy and military strategy and
navigated the crushing restraints of domestic politics. As the Supreme Allied Commander,
Europe, the author faced a task far more daunting than simply when and where to
deploy his forces and weapons. The author also had to mediate numerous
conflicts that threatened to derail the alliance's efforts against the regime
of Yugoslav President Slobodan Milosevic - conflicts between the Europeans and
the Americans, between the policy makers and the journalists, between the
diplomats and the military men. The war in Kosovo may have been short in
duration, but it was a harbinger of the new realities of war-fighting and
war-planning, and the author offers a blueprint for how modern militaries must
adapt to meet the challenges of a new era.
One Year After NATO Bombardments in Yugoslavia:
Security Issues, Common Policy Approaches and Public Perception: 2000-2002. A
Report submited by IPER to NATO Office of Information and Press.
Europe and the Breakup of Yugoslavia: A Political
Failure in Search of a Scholarly Explanation / Sonia Lucarelli - The Hague :
Kluwer Law International, 2000.
On June 26, 1991, after some forty-six years
without a war in Europe, violent conflict erupted in the territory of what used
to be the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. It took more than four
years of atrocities before a peace agreement was finally negotiated in Dayton,
Ohio in November 1995. This book provides a detailed analysis of the response
of Western Europe to the disintegration of Yugoslavia. The account pays
particular attention to the behaviour of the major Member States of the
European Community (later Union), i.e. France, Britain and Germany, in two
crucial moments of debate and decision-making : the diplomatic recognition of
Slovenia and Croatia in 1991, and the debate on the desirability and form of a
possible military intervention in the warring country. By combining three
theoretical approaches to the study of international politics - neorealism,
neoliberal institutionalism and liberal intergovernmentalism - the author
provides a theoretically informed analysis of the main forces behind Western Europe's
response to the Yugoslav wars. Conclusions are drawn on the major
characteristics of Western Europe's management of the conflict, the interplay
of international and domestic factors behind the behaviour of Western European
states, the relative explanatory power of each of the three theoretical
perspectives and their common research tradition, and the prospective of the
Common Foreign and Security Policy of the European Union. The book's
reconstruction and evaluation of conflict management in ex-Yugoslavia, its
attention on the influence of the European integration process on the foreign
policy of its Member States, and its innovative use and assessment of
International Relations theoretical tools, make it of topical interest for a
wide range of scholars interested in both international and European political
affairs.
Croatia: Three Elections and a Funeral / Trevor
Waters - Camberley, UK: Conflict Studies Research Centre, 2000.
Croatia's passage into the new millennium was
marked by the death, on 10 December 1999, of the self-proclaimed 'Father of the
Nation', President Dr. Franjo Tudjman; by make or break Parliamentary
Elections, held on 3 January 2000, which secured the crushing defeat of the
former president's ruling Croatian Democratic Union, yielded victory for an
alliance of the six mainstream opposition parties, and ushered in a new
coalition government strong enough to implement far-reaching reform; and by two
rounds, on 24 January and 7 February, of Presidential Elections which resulted
in a surprising and spectacular victory for the charismatic Stipe Mesic,
Yugoslavia's last president, nonetheless considered by many Croats at the start
of the campaing as an outsider, a man from the past. These turn of the century
events are viewed as beneficial for the development of genuine democracy in the
newly independent state, as heralding the dawn of a vibrant 'Democroatia', and
thus smoothing the way for the country's integration into Euro-Atlantic
structures. This paper reviews the events and affirms - albeit cautiously -
such positive hopes for the future.
Reconciliation via the War Crimes Tribunal? /
Aleksandar Fatic - Aldershot, UK: Ashgate, 2000.
This is an examination of the issues of
reconciliation after civil wars and the role international war crimes tribunals
play in facilitating that reconciliation, apart from enforcing justice against
perpetrators of war crimes. This book argues that war crime tribunals are
partial and will be counterproductive.
Slovenia and the Slovenes: A Small State and the
New Europe / James Gow, Cathie Carmichael - London : Hurst, 2000.
This volume is the first serious assessment of
Slovenia and the Slovenes in English, and looks critically at the history of
the people and the land, the impact of geography and the national language on
culture, society and politics, as well as the Slovenian experience of the
Yugoslav state and the evolution towards, preparation for and development after
independence. The book goes against the
grain of recent Slovenian academic writing which has tended to skip over the
more than seventy years of incorporation within federal Yugoslavia and diminish
the value of that long period for the Slovenians, regarding it as something of
an aberration. Instead, the authors argue here that, while the peculiarities of
Slovene as a language have fostered a separate identity for its speakers, the
Slovenian state which emerged was a direct product of Yugoslavia.
NATO's Empty Victory : A Postmortem on the Balkan
War / ed. by Ted Galen Carpenter - Washington : Cato Institute, 2000.
NATO political leaders claim that the war against
Yugoslavia was a great victory, the authors of these essays disagree. The war
lasted for longer than anticipated and triggered a refugee crisis. The book
offers proposals for preventing the 'victory' becoming an even bigger policy
fiasco.
Origins of a Catastrophe: Yugoslavia and Its
Destroyers / Warren Zimmermann - New York: Times Books, 1999.
In this revised edition, Warren Zimmermann, the
last US ambassador to Yugoslavia, updates his prescient account of the
catastrophe now occurring in the Balkans. He provides an insightful analysis of
what has happened in Bosnia since the Dayton accord, of the war and ethnic
cleansing taking place in Kosovo, and of why America has become involved.
Dubious Mandate: A Memoir of the UN in Bosnia,
Summer 1995 / Phillip Corwin - Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1999.
A critical year in the history of peacekeeping,
1995 saw the dramatic transformation of the role of United Nations' forces in
Bosnia from being a protective force to being an active combatant under NATO
leadership. Phillip Corwin, the UN's chief political officer in Sarajevo during
the summer of that year, presents a first-person, insider's account of the
momentous events that led to that transformation. The book interweaves personal
experiences of daily life in a war zone - supply shortages, human suffering,
assassination attempts, corruption - with historical facts, as Corwin
challenges commonly held views of the war with his own highly informed,
discerning, and trenchant political commentary.
Operation Deliberate Force: the UN and NATO
Campaign in Bosnia 1995 / Tim Ripley - Lancaster : Centre for Defence and
International Security Studies, 1999.
During the evening of 10th September 1995, thirteen
US Navy Tomahawk cruise missiles devasted a Bosnian Serb communications tower
in the climax of a joint NATO and UN military operation to lift the siege of
Sarajevo. Three days later Serb leaders agreed to pull their guns back and two
months later the Dayton Peace Accords ended the war. This book tells for the
first time the inside story of the military moves that brought three year long
Bosnian war to an end. Senior western military commanders, UN 'blue helmets',
and NATO airmen describe their roller-coaster year, from the disasters of the
spring and summer of 1995 through to launching of Operation Deliberate Force in
August and September.
UN Peacekeeping in Trouble: Lessons Learned from
the Former Yugoslavia: Peacekeepers' Views on the Limits and Possibilities of
the United Nations in a Civil War-like Conflict / ed. by Wolfgang Bierman and
Martin Vadset - Aldershot, UK: Ashgate, 1999.
This book is intended to fill a gap in the
literature about peacekeeping in the former Yugoslavia through a combination of
empirical methods. The project combines qualitative research with quantitative
methods to analyse the views of the practitioners on different aspects of peacekeeping
and conflict mediation.
La France et la
gestion des conflits yougoslaves (1991-1995): enjeux et lecons d'une operation
de maintien de la paix de l'ONU / Thierry Tardy - Bruxelles: Bruylant, 1999.
Forging War: The Media in Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia
and Hercegovina / Mark Thompson - Luton: University of Luton Press, 1999.
The author's purpose in this undertaking is to
document and analyse the subordination of news media in Serbia, Croatia and
Bosnia-Herzegovina to national agendas and to direct or indirect control by the
given regime. With exhaustive and thorough documentation based on both printed
and broadcast media in these three states, Thompson shows how independent media
were variously suppressed or taken over by the respective regimes. The media
played a key role in heating up tensions prior to the war and in reinforcing
nationalist notions of self-righteousness. Misrepresentation and distortion
became commonplace in the post-Yugoslav media. Most people now recognize that a
strong independent media is an essential prerequisite of an enduring democracy.
Thompson's analysis of what we might call the ethnic nationalist media in
Serbia, Bosnia and Croatia makes clear their role in literally forging the war.
The fragmentation of the media in what was formerly Yugoslavia both contributed
to and presently reinforces the causes of conflict.
Serbia Under Milosevic: Politics in the 1990s /
Robert Thomas - London : Hurst, 1999.
This study examines, in the context of Serbia's
political and cultural development, how in the late 1980s a faction within the
Serbian Communist Party, led by Slobodan Milosevic, was able to exploit
national and constitutional tensions within the former Yugoslavia in order to
preserve its power.
Target Bosnia: Integrating Information Activities
in Peace Operations: NATO-Led Operations in Bosnia-Herzegovina, December 1995-1997
/ Pascale Combelles-Siegel - Washington : National Defense University Press,
1998.
With each day that passes drawing us further down
the path from the Industrial to the Information age, many officers are
convinced that victory is no longer determined on the ground, but in media
reporting. This is even more true in peace support operations (PSO) where the
goal is not to conquer territory or defeat an enemy but to persuade parties in
conflict (as well as the local populations) into a favored course of action.
This monograph examines the role of information in PSO and its impact on
command and control through the prism of NATO-led operations in
Bosnia-Herzegovina from December 1995 into 1997.
The Issues Raised by Bosnia, and the Transatlantic
Debate - Paris: Institute for Security Studies of Western European Union, 1998.
The aim of this paper is to analyse definitions
regarding the future shape of Bosnia (integration or partition), the practical
implementation of Dayton, the different scenarios for an international presence
in Bosnia (progressive withdrawal, short-term or long-term presence, a
deterrent or reconstruction force), as well as transatlantic relations
(competition or cooperation). The four authors have been invited to follow the
same framework of analysis, reviewing the problems mentioned above while
endeavouring to set out the specific positions of their respective countries :
Germany, France, the United Kingdom and the United States. Using a common
framework of analysis should allow a comparison of the approach to developments
in the European security agenda taken by the most important actors, in
particular the European partners, to be made.
Bosnia and the New Collective Security / Elinor
Camille Sloan - Westport, CT: Praeger, 1998.
This work examines two complex and interrelated
topics : the role of ìpeacekeeping and related operations in managing
nontraditional crises, ìand the international community's response to the
recent conflict in ìBosnia. The author explains the changing nature of international
ìinvolvement and draws out lessons for the future.
Blue Helmets: The Strategy of UN Military
Operations / John Hillen - Washington : Brassey's, 1998.
This book is the first to comprehensively address
the performance of the United Nations over the past fifty years as an employer
of military force and to examine the organization's ability to handle military
operations. Analyzing thirty-eight UN military operations conducted worldwide
since 1948, international security expert John Hillen answers important
questions about the UN's competency to handle complex future operations. With
UN operations now costing billions of dollars each year and involving tens of
thousands of troops in dangerous operations, many observers have questioned
what the appropriate role of the UN should be in global security. Dr. Hillen's
conclusions, which include timely postmortems of UN operations in the former
Yugoslavia and Somalia, may have a profound impact on the future of collective
security. With a foreword by Ambassador Robert Oakley, this book is essential
reading for anyone interested in the United Nations and international security
in today's volatile world.
Projecting Stability : NATO and Multilateral Naval
Cooperation in the Post Cold War Era / Joel J Sokolsky - Halifax, NS: Dalhousie
University, 1998.
The purpose of this study is to examine NATO
multinational maritime cooperation in the post-Cold War era and assess its
effectiveness in supporting the new objectives of the Atlantic Alliance. The
study begins with a discussion of sea power in the post-Cold War era with
particular reference to NATO. This is followed by a brief overview of the state
of the Russian Navy. It then turns to a review of the ways in which the
Alliance has tried to adjust its maritime organization and posture in order to
accommodate the changed international strategic environment. The next section
looks specifically at the role of the Alliance's maritime forces in peace
support missions, particularly in the former Yugoslavia. This is followed by a
discussion of the approach of the USN to maritime multilateralism before
turning to maritime implications of creating a distinctively European
multinational maritime structure. Finally, the paper looks across the Atlantic
to Canada and the role that its navy has and can play within the larger allied
maritime framework.
Replacing SFOR in Bosnia: Options for a DFOR in
1998 / Michael Clarke, Andrew Duncan - London: Brassey's, 1997.
As the end of the mandate of the NATO-led
multinational Stabilisation Force in Bosnia approaches in June 1998 questions
regarding a successor force are now being urgently addressed. The desirability
and practicability of a successor force is dependent upon a series of difficult
contingent questions, all of which have to be answered in some way before a
successor force can be either established or discounted. Such questions revolve
around the likely outcome in Bosnia if SFOR were not replaced; an assessment of
the success of the Dayton Accords and a consideration of whether the military
can do more to increase its effectiveness; the question of whether the United
States will remain in any new arrangement, and if it does not, whether the
Europeans will shoulder the responsibility; whether the Europeans have the
required military strength and political will to do so; the problem of the size
of any new force - on present trends it might be smaller, but it would almost
certainly have to be reinforced if Dayton is to be, in effect, imposed upon the
parties.
Lessons from Bosnia: The IFOR Experience / ed. by
Larry K. Wentz - Vienna, VA: CCRP, 1997.
The Road to Peace : NATO and the International
Community in Bosnia / Rupert Wolfe Murray - Edinburgh: Connect, 1997.
Many of the world's leading international
organisations are spending millions of dollars in an attempt to kick start the
democratic process and economic regeneration in Bosnia. However, Bosnia is
still a divided country where tensions between the former warring parties run
high and much of the Dayton Peace Agreement, signed by all parties, is being
blatantly ignored. Unless international law prevails, beginning with the arrest
and trial of the indicted war criminals, it is hard to see how the withdrawal
of SFOR troops in 1998 can lead to anything but a renewal of war. This book gives
a unique insight into the role of the NATO peacekeepers in Bosnia. In a series
of commentaries, and exclusive interviews with key people in SFOR and
organisations such as the International Police Task Force, the United Nations
High Commission for Refugees, and the Overseas Development Administration, this
book assesses the chances of a lasting peace.
U.S. Participation in IFOR : A Marathon, Not a
Sprint / William Thomas Johnsen - Carlisle Barracks, PA: US Army War College,
1996.
The US decision to join the Implementation Force
(IFOR) for the General Framework Agreement for Peace in Bosnia and Hercegovina
(familiarly known as the Dayton Accords) marked a crucial milestone toward
achieving the US national objective of a lasting political settlement to the conflict
in Bosnia. Equally critical will be determining whether the United States will
continue participating in IFOR beyond the currently established 12-month
deadline.
IFOR on IFOR: NATO Peacekeepers in
Bosnia-Herzegovina / ed. by Rupert Wolfe Murray - Edinburgh: Connect, 1996.
This book is a unique account of the NATO-led
mission in Bosnia. Using specially commissioned photographs and interviews, it
looks at the work, equipment and opinions of the people behind the force.
Post-Mortem on UNPROFOR / Richard Caplan - London:
Brassey's, 1996.
This study examines the UN's peacekeeping
operation in the former Yugoslavia, the United Nations Protection Force
(UNPROFOR), from its inception in February 1992 to its effective termination in
January 1996. Not since the UN intervention in the Congo in the early 1960s
have UN peacekeepers been involved in a more controversial operation - and one
that by the Organization's own admission exhibited only limited success. This
study explores why, despite some notable achievements, UNPROFOR largely failed
to meet its stated objectives. It also draws lessons from the experience for UN
peacekeeping reform.
Yugoslavia Through Documents : From Its Creation
to Its Dissolution / ed. by Snezana Trifunovska - Dordrecht: Nijhoff, 1994.
This book contains more than 360 documents
relevant to the international legal position of the Yugoslav terrorities in the
19th century, the creation of Yugoslavia as a common state of the
Serbs, Croats and Slovenes, 1918, its constitutional development and the
process of dissolution of Yugoslavia and the creation of the new states of
Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia and the Federal Republic
of Yugoslavia.
Lessons of Yugoslavia / Nicole Gnesotto - Paris:
Institute for Security Studies of Western European Union, 1994.
The United Nations and NATO in Former Yugoslavia:
Partners in International Cooperation / Dick A. Leurdijk ; ed. by Auke . Venema
- The Hague: Netherlands Atlantic Commission, 1994.
This study on the evolving relationship between
the United Nations and the North Atlantic Alliance is also a useful summary of
events relating to the former Yugoslavia. Furthermore, it includes an appendix
on the decision-making by the United Nations Security Council concerning the
former Yugoslavia.
Analyses of the Conflict in Former Yugoslavia /
Anton Zakbar - Vienna: National Defence Academy, 1994.
Peace Conference on Former Yugoslavia: The
Politico-Military Interface / Graham Messervy-Whitting - London: Brassey's,
1994.
The aim of this study is to examine the
politico-military interface in the Conference's relations with the local
parties, with other international bodies and national governments, with the
agencies on the ground, then within ICFY itself, during the period ended August
1993. A chronological summary, covering the period up until August 1993 of
ICFY's main activities, is annexed for the record.
Europe and Yugoslavia : Lessons from a Failure /
Jonathan Eyal - London: Royal United Services Institute for Defence Studies,
1993.
Articles
Thies, Wallace J.
Compellence Failure or
Coercive Success? The case of NATO and Yugoslavia.
COMPARATIVE STRATEGY,
vol. 22, no. 3, 2003, p. 243-267.
What is coercion? How
does it work? Much recent work in this regard has centered on two issues : the
relative merits of punishment versus denial strategies, and whether air power
can work in the absence of forces on the ground. These are important issues,
but they also convey the misleading impression that coercion is something that
occurs after the first bomb is dropped. This paper argues than an air war is
better viewed as a last resort that occurs only after the failure to deter
and/or compel by means of verbal threats and threatening gestures. Whether such
verbal threats and threatening gestures are done well or poorly will go a long
way toward explaining 1) whether an air war is necessary at all, 2) how long
and how hard the target will resist, and 3) whether the target can be coerced
at a price a coercer is willing to pay. To illustrate these points, the paper
re-examines four instances of deterrence and compellence that precedes NATO's
1999 air war against Yugoslavia over Kosovo. Theses four episodes are used to
shed new light on why the air war was necessary, why it took much longer than
expected for air power to 'work', and why the Yugoslav government led by
Slobodan Milosevic thought it could get away with depopulating Kosovo of its
ethnic Albanian majority.
Popovski, Vesselin
The UN Security Council
Approach to the Conflicts in Former Yugoslavia.
JOURNAL OF SOUTHEAST
EUROPEAN AND BLACK SEA STUDIES, vol. 2, no. 3, September 2002, p. 39-62.
This article analyses UN
Security Council resolutions taken in respect to the former Yugoslavia,
revealing their specifics and comparative (dis)advantages to the Security
Council involvement in other conflicts. It shows how the Security Council
enlarged the interpretation of what may constitute a 'threat to international
peace and security', what innovative actions were undertaken and how the
concept of sanctions gradually evolved from blanket economic sanctions against
states into targeted measures against individuals.
Simic, Predrag
Russia and the Conflicts
in the Former Yugoslavia.
JOURNAL OF SOUTHEAST
EUROPEAN AND BLACK SEA STUDIES, vol. 1, no. 3, September 2001, p. 95-114.
Moscow's efforts to
redefine its national interests and relations with the West in the post-Cold
War era has directed the country's stance towards the conflicts in former
Yugoslavia. Russia's intention to present itself as an influential power in the
international efforts to manage the crises following the dissolution of
Yugoslavia largely explains Moscow's frequently contradictory stances, not only
towards the wars in Bosnia and Kosovo, but also in its intention to play the
role of an effective mediator in the region. At the same time, Russia'
strategic concern to sustain its international standing and influence through
its membership in international organizations, such as the UN and OSCE, has
rendered Moscow as the state that considers the weakening of those
organizations as one of its external security threats.
Rupnik, Jacques
Yugoslavia After
Milosevic.
SURVIVAL, vol. 43, no.
2, Summer 2001, p. 19-29.
The wars of Yugoslavia's
dissolution might not be over yet. There remains much unfinished business,
including, most urgently, the question of Kosovo's future status. If left
unresolved, this question could well trigger a new round of violence and
instability. If an obvious and satisfactory solution existed, it would already
be known. None of the available options - including a reconfigured Yugoslavia
containing an autonomous Kosovo, an indefinite international protectorate, or
Kosovo's partition - are appealing. The least problematic option is probably to
prepare Kosovo for a form of 'conditional' independence, with heavy
international supervision of minority rights and guarantees against further
revisions of borders. This would require the new Serb leadership to make a
clean break with the Milosevic era and the myth of Serbian 'reconquest' of
Kosovo. It also would require Kosovo Albanian leadership that is mature enough
to embrace a twenty-first century - rather than a nineteenth-century - concept
of sovereignty.
Tsygankov, Andrei P.
The Final Triumph of the
Pax Americana? Western Intervention in Yugoslavia and Russia's Debate on the
Post-Cold War Order.
COMMUNIST AND
POST-COMMUNIST STUDIES, vol. 34, no. 2, June 2001, p. 133-156.
This paper addresses the
question of world order by considering how Western military actions in
Yugoslavia were perceived from a different cultural perspective. It traces how
the NATO-led bombing campaign during March-June of 1999 affected various
visions of world order that had existed in Russia before the campaign and
describes the discursive change this campaign produced. The argument is made
that Russia's foreign policy elites, from Westernizers to Neo-Communists and
Expansionists, perceived Western goals in Yugoslavia differently from their
counterparts in the West. However, they differed in their recommendations
regarding Russia's response and lessons to be drawn from the Kosovo crisis. The
paper also identifies several points where the different perspectives can
converge. More specifically, all Russian schools of thought viewed the NATO
campaign as a dangerous precedent potentially destabilizing the existing world
order. They also shared the conviction that Russia should play a larger role in
world affairs and that without Russia's involvement there could be no peace and
stability in the Balkans and in Europe. They point to the UN as the only forum
for debating the legitimacy of military interventions and for preventing
interventions carried out without the approval of the UN.
Uzgel, Ihlan
Finishing the Unfinished
Revolution : the Return of Yugoslavia to Europe.
PERCEPTIONS, vol. 6, no.
1, March - May 2001, p. 151-165.
Gordy, Eric D.
Building a 'Normal,
Boring' Country : Kostunica's Yugoslavia.
CURRENT HISTORY, vol.
1000, no. 644, March 2001, p. 109-113.
The fall of the
Milosevic regime has much meanings in itself, and a strong desire to imagine a
better future can be sensed everywhere. But nothing is assured unless the new
government is able to make this desire concrete.
Sandhal, Erik
Humanitarian Demining in
Peace Support Operations : NATO's Experience in Former Yugoslavia.
MILITARY TECHNOLOGY,
vol. 24, no. 11, 2000, p. 32-35.
The primary mission for
troops deployed in Peace Support Operations (PSO's) is to provide a secure
environment in which the population can live in normal conditions and the civil
organisations can work safely to rebuild countries ravaged by war. Mine
clearance and demining are key priorities for both international military
forces and specialized UN agencies and Non-Governmental Organisations (NGO's)
in this process, especially in areas where refugees and displaced persons are
expected to return in their homes. These vital tasks also provide a good
example of how civil and military may work together.
Karadzole, Boran
The Power of Deception :
Yugoslavia in the Aftermath of the Confrontation with NATO.
PERCEPTIONS, vol. 5, no.
1, March - May 2000, p. 147-160.
Chernichenko, S.
NATO's Operation in
Yugoslavia.
INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS
(Minneapolis), vol. 46, no. 1, 2000, p. 168-177.
Ronzitti, Natalino
Lessons of International
Law from NATO's Armed Intervention Against the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia.
INTERNATIONAL SPECTATOR,
vol. 34, no. 3, July - September 1999, p. 45-54.
The author discusses the
various official and academic arguments put forward regarding the legality of
NATO's military action, undertaken without authorisation from the UN Security
Council, and the problems associated with the effort to establish a convincing
doctrine of humanitarian intervention. He examines how the search for a new
legitimacy of international actions against countries that violate fundamental
human rights can be satisfied without undermining the essential role of the UN
System. In the concluding part of the article, the author argues in favour of
the Security Council giving a general authorisation - as opposed to a
case-by-case one - to regional organisations to undertake enforcement actions,
while maintaining the ultimate power to stop them.
Williams, John
The Ethical Basis of
Humanitarian Intervention, the Security Council and Yugoslavia.
INTERNATIONAL PEACEKEEPING,
vol. 6, no. 2, Summer 1999, p. 1-23.
The article analyses the
text of Security Council Resolutions on the conflict in the former Yugoslavia
for the period between September 1991 and 1997. It searches for evidence of a
shift on the part of the Council towards an acceptance of the idea of universal
human rights and their importance to international peace and security. The
article concludes that the Resolutions do suggest that such a shift is
underway, and this contributes to a greater concern for justice as an element
of order in international relations.
Sharp, Jane M. O.
Missed Opportunities in
Former Yugoslavia.
STUDIA DIPLOMATICA, vol.
51, no. 6, 1998, p. 15-24.
Liotta, P. H.
The Ethics of
Intervention in the Former Yugoslavia.
EUROPEAN SECURITY, vol.
7, no. 4, Winter 1998, p. 33-68.
The United States'
intervention, diplomatically and militarily, in former Yugoslavia demonstrates
the complexities of social justice in post-Cold War Europe. Nominally an action
to support 'vital' American interests, intervention equally involved a moral
and ethical choice to leverage military technology and to prevent the spread of
Balkan violence. Ethical politics, as Reinhold Niebuhr defines it, is an area
where conscience and power meet, where ethical and coercive factors
'interpenetrate' in an uneasy compromise. Whether or not the will to a
political ethic is sufficient to bring social justice to the former Yugoslavia
remains unclear.
Schulte, Gregory L.
Former Yugoslavia and
the New NATO.
SURVIVAL, vol. 39, no. 1,
Spring 1997, p. 19-42.
NATO's involvement in
former Yugoslavia has graphically illustrated how the Alliance has adapted
since the Cold War. At the same time, this involvement has given impetus and
reality to many aspects of NATO's transformation. With the Peace Implementation
Force (IFOR) and now the Stabilisation Force (SFOR), NATO is operating 'out of
area', with all 16 allies and in coalition with forces from over half the
countries in its Partnership for Peace (PfP) programme. NATO has established practical
cooperation with the UN, the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in
Europe (OSCE) and other international organisations. A major lesson from this
experience is the need to ensure that future peace-support missions are clearly
defined and backed by adequate mandates and resources. NATO will also want to
develop its capabilities for civil-military cooperation and to establish
standing mechanisms to incorporate Russia and other PfP countries into future
operations.